Ain’t It Cool News posted major spoilers for the Battlestar Galatica finale on their web site. If the details of the finale are true, they jibe with my theory about BSG, which could provide answers to the larger mysteries of the show.
MAJOR spoilers below, so keep reading only if you’ve seen every BSG to date. I’ve avoided references to the Ain’t It Cool News spoilers for those who still need to see the final episode of this season.
SPOILERS
s
p
o
i
l
e
r
s
My theory: They’re All Cylons.
All humans on BSG are Cylons. Every one is a unique model, with a corresponding model waiting to be resurrected on “Earth.” When a human dies (as Starbuck did two episodes ago) he or she wakes up on Earth. All beings known as “Cylons” are actually outdated models of Cylon; the real Cylons are the 13th colony of humans which now exist on Earth in an advanced state of existence.
If true, here are my answers to the major questions of the show:
Is Starbuck dead?
Starbuck did “die” when her body exploded in the maelstrom, but immediately woke up on Earth on the 13th colony equivalent of a resurrection ship. This is the thing that she was destined to do – be the first human to pass over to the other side (Earth, where the 13th colony lives) and meet the humans living there. This is why she says “they’re waiting for me” before her ship explodes, why Leoben (her Cylon stalker) keeps telling her death is not hard to embrace, and why she will see Lee “on the other side.”
I predict Starbuck will return in some form, to lead the BSG humans back to Earth.
Do other people know they’re Cylons?
Sort of. Chief Tyrol and Baltar have already thought they were Cylons, and if Ain’t It Cool is accurate, more people will think they’re Cylons before the season ends.
However, the truth is that everyone’s a Cylon – it’s just that some of them are more sensitive to their Cylon nature than others. Until someone dies (and wakes up on Earth in a new body) they don’t realize their true Cylon nature.
This, again, fits in with Starbuck’s destiny – to show the humans on Galactica that the true way to Earth is through death (and resurrection).
If everyone’s a Cylon, what’s with the current Cylons (Six, Leoben, the Priest, etc)?
Right now there are seven humanoid Cylons we know about, and a set of “final five” Cylons that have been seen in a vision.
The current Cylons (like Six) are an outdated model of Cylon. These humanoid Cylon have “tribes” that all look alike – all the Sixes are blond models, all the Threes look like Lucy Lawless, etc. However, the “13th tribe” represents a new breed of Cylon which have evolved to have individual looks – so there is a model for a Chief Tyrol, but ONLY ONE unit looks like a Chief Tyrol. If Tyrol were to die in the hangar bay, his consciousness would be downloaded to a Tyrol unit on Earth and would wake up in a new Tyrol-shaped body.
I’d further hypothesize that the 12 tribes that currently exist in the humans are analogous to the 12 tribes of Cylons. So the Caprican tribe of humans on Galactica is actually a race of worker Cylons – each one on Galactica corresponding to a unit existing in the 13th tribe on Earth.
What’s going to happen?
The 13th tribe is waiting for Galactica humans and Cylons back on the real Earth. They’ll send Starbuck to BSG to guide the way home.
The current Cylons (Six, etc.) are in the dark about the 13th tribe Cylons waiting on Earth. Over the next season they will continue to chase Galactica through space, as the true nature of the Earth Cylons is revealed.
More people on BSG will start thinking they’re Cylons. Â Debate will rage on message boards and wikis about who is and isn’t a Cylon, until all are revealed to be Cylons.
Possibly, the last episode of the series will end with BSG and all the humans dying… only to be reborn in new bodies on Earth. This would fit in with the overall theme of spirituality and resurrection that’s run throughout the series so far.
END SPOILERS
To say more would spoil next week’s grand finale, so I’ll hold off on saying more till the episode has aired.